"the hotel has not been kept up, peeling paint, bulgibng walls, they charged multpe guests a $500 smoking fee and they were not smokers or even in the room when they made the claim, nobody helped, would not adjust the bill... what a mess; horrible"

"The New Yorker is in an ideal location for anyone arriving at Penn Station or attending an event at MSG. It is an older hotel so some of the rooms are small but they are clean with daily maid service. The lobby is large, clean and inviting and all employees are very helpful and friendly. The Tick Tock Restaurant is open 24/7 with all day breakfast and good food. I certainly would return for a future trip."

"E"

"Great location. Rooms were small but clean and had everything you need. Lovely first floor lounge and cafe area."

"Fantastic Location. Great Staff. Amenities not so much. Tiny room, has the basics; but not the neatest/cleanest. Some mold in the restroom, Ice Machine did not work, ice buckets not available in rooms. If you are looking for a quick place to rest, and quick shower wearing sandals, and are under strict budget, go for it. Else, keep looking for a better option."