Search Motels in Shelter Island

"Nice weekend getaway. Will return."

"Wonderful Hotel Stay We had such a great experience here! The staff was warm and welcoming, and the hotel itself had everything we needed. The pool and jacuzzi were perfect for relaxing, and our room was a very comfortable size. In the evenings, the firepit was such a cozy spot to unwind. The location was fantastic—bikes were available to get around, which made everything so easy. We took a ride to the beach and a winery for the day, and even grabbed breakfast nearby with just a quick bike ride. Overall, a wonderful stay with the perfect mix of comfort, relaxation, and convenience. Highly recommend!"

"Great location ,beautiful hotel,nice staff"

"very nice."

"We have stayed at a lot of different places over the years, But this by far was our best trip to date. The property was all that was promised. Clean and beautiful. It’s a must stay if your heading to Montauk."

"Beautiful hotel ,staff very efficient and friendly lifts to the rooms were very fast Lovely size room with very comfortable beds ,lovely view over the pool and the lake from the room. Breakfast was not included in our booking but we paid for the breakfast in the hotel which was very filling and varied each morning plenty of coffee available also fresh fruit pancakes and eggs. Plenty of information at reception of what was popular in the area Winery visits were popular The hotel has a very interesting Aquarium next door . This is a beautiful hotel just 1.5 hrs outside New York we travelled by train and got a taxi from the station where there were plenty of Taxis available at a reasonable cost "

"We are a family of four, and this hotel was absolutely perfect for us. It’s very family-friendly, and the staff went above and beyond with exceptional service throughout our stay. The Ocean Club restaurant had plenty of options, even for our picky eaters, which made mealtimes stress-free. The pools and beach areas were well maintained, with great service all around. We had such a wonderful experience and will definitely be back!"

"The salt water pool was awesome! Would have liked it a little bit warmer. Breakfast was great, eggs, sausage, English muffins, bagels coffee,tea, waffles, fruit, cereal, juice! Rooms were spacious with fridge. Would highly recommend "

"Nice staff and the hotel is fine. "