Search Cabin Rentals in Shelter Island

"I love this place. Next time I wish I could have a better view. I went there before the new rooms were added. Every time I went there, I stayed in the main building right upstairs from the check-in facing the water with my husband and I absolutely loved it. I was actually married there in the old ballroom. I was put in a room that I faced the side of the building and parking lot. I like it there because you can have your meals there if you want they should put a microwave in the rooms. I grew up there on the shore when I was a kid so it is a very pretty place. I think it’s understaffed. I saw the same woman there almost 3 shifts in a row. I think she was a manager. She was delivering drinks, which I thought was crazy and then I saw her the next morning at breakfast time being the hostess, I said to her, don’t you ever get a day off she said thank you for noticing. She was a very pleasant, nice woman, but I think it’s understaffed. I stayed there during the wrong time of year. It was spring break. Children were running up and down the hallway, which was not appropriate And they were with a parent. That’s what really got me - back in the day when I was a parent of young children, I would never let my children run up and down the hallways but times are different now -not for the better!!!"

"it was great. staff were super friendly an helpful. shuttle service was super convinient"

"Great location! On the bay but walking distance to town "

"The room was clean. The property was well kept. The town is a block away so you can walk to everything."

"First I want to sincerely apologize my 3 year girl got really sick on the last day. But overall experience was amazing my favorite thing about this hotel was the staff how they how they were with us how they were my daughter when she was playing with them do sincerely appreciate that made her birthday week even better."

"This is a super elevated motel vibe. Area is janky but accommodations were excellent."

"Good "

"Kenny isn't the Tipp, he's the Tops"

"The staff was kind and very hospitable. Very beautiful environment and clean place to stay. "