Search Cottages in Shelter Island

"Great stay. Would stay again. "

"Myself my BF and my dog had a wonderful time."

"The little cottage in quaint Jamesport was perfect! Felt like you were back in simpler times and able to walk to near restaurants/ beach. Joe was always responsive with all questions. Hope to visit again soon! "

"Loved the salt marsh with all the birds. The views at the beach were amazing! Scott and Mary-Jo were wonderful! I would definitely stay again!"

"Perfect little beachfront cottage right on the water ...a few steps across your own beach. We had a very relaxing, comfortable visit."

"This property is perfect for 2-3 guests and located within short distance to town. The house is well built and very clean. Five Stars"

"Great host and property"

"This was the best place to celebrate my family member’s 60th! Being right on the water was amazing! We enjoyed the outdoor fire pit, the beachy air and the outdoor setting. Inside was clean and adorable. The bunk beds were much larger than appears in the picture. If you want a little getaway to enjoy the salty air, I highly recommend! The owner was very timely in getting back regarding any questions I had and was friendly. "

"Our family stayed at this quaint cottage in the North Fork. The cottage has a nice kitchen, gas fireplace, and well appointed bedrooms. I would love to visit in summer, it must be wonderful!"

"A perfect stay - John and his family were truly wonderful. The house is attached to thier main house, but also very private and secure. We were in town for a wedding weekend and this was the perfect spot for us - truly a beatuiful property! John was helpful in telling us about all of the local spot and supplying us with everything we needed. His wife even welcomed us with a cheese board and wine! Thanks John and family - we had a great time!"