Find all hotels by Independent in Shelter Island, NY from SAR 300

"Great"

"We always have a great stay at Aqualina. Can’t wait to come back next year. Thank you to all the staff. "

"The water views of the Sound were spectacular & were accessible for every meal. The staff was friendly & accommodating -- they had lots of good meal recommendations both in house & for outside restaurants. This inn had a very peaceful vibe -- would definitely return!"

"The room was very nice and the staff were all very helpful. The only small negatives were the TV was mounted at an angle and the bathroom countertops were very low"

"Beachcomber was perfect! We had a blast and will definitely stay here again"

"Friendly staff, great location, water views "

"We could not recommend this property more! The rooms are fabulous and the grounds are beautiful. We had a room on the ground and our dog loved the easy access outside. The rooms are decorated beautifully as well - very chic and spacious! Cant wait to come back here in the Fall."

"Such a great experience! Clean and beautiful renovations. Such accommodating and great staff. Very convenient to town and the beach. Can’t wait to go back "

"We really enjoyed the location. It was perfect for us with a toddler. Had a lot of fun in the pool and enjoyed the surrounding restaurants and aquarium. The room was comfortable and clean. The Riverwalk behind the hotel is a beautiful walk to end the day. "