Find Hotels with a Pool in Shelter Island, NY

"We stayed 5 days! Customer service was great ;) Housekeeping was great, the cafe in the morning was excellent! Lounge area if you wanted to go out in the evening they had Pool, Darts, & Karaoke If you didn't want to go to the Beach, they had a Pool/Gym Right near the Highway & Route 1 We had a wonderful Stay!!...Will definitely go back!!! Gave them 5 Stars ;)"

"Excellent "

"Had a 2 day girls trip and really enjoyed staying at the hotel. Staff was so nice and accommodations top notch. "

"Can’t say enough about how great this place was! The location is amazing. Steps away from the beach one way and a block away from the heart of the town and shops. I will definitely be staying here every year I come back to Montauk."

"Javier ( manager), Luisa (pool attendant) and staff were exceptional!!!! The accommodation and considerations were so great. We only stayed one night but aren’t leaving without booking another trip soon. Btw, the food for adults were fantastic, however nothing to accommodate the kids which was weird since the place is so kid friendly. "

"Took a chance on a last minute two night family getaway and I am so glad we did. Check in could not have been faster and kinder, shout out to Daren you are a treasure of a human! It’s a really cute, updated motel/hotel, the grounds are beautiful and clean as are the rooms. Compared to other places like this, this was absolutely more spacious and had more amenities. Deck, and sand area were great to hangout on, we played some games and had a blast. Day one we hung around at the pool and did the generous $10 beach pass from the Bayview the 2nd day and spent a great day at the beach. You need a car here in order to go to local resturants, coffee places (although there is morning coffee in the communal lounge and a coffee maker in the room) Mini fridge and microwave was a huge help with young kids. They really make this place easy to be a guest at, are happy to give extra towels and everyone was super friendly. If anyone is complaining here I would not understand why. We will be back!"

"Fantastic!! Loved staying at this luxurious hotel "

"We've been coming to The Beach Comber for years. The Staff are always pleasant and accommodating. The rooms are spacious, spotless and have. A great view of the Ocean & pool. Love this place!"

"Great staff clean. "