Find Pet-friendly Hotels in Shelter Island Heights, NY

"Property was amazing for our stay in Shelter Island "

"Beautiful views and lovely service "

"It was a beautiful place! Under construction however, Beth was Amazing! Amelia was so hospitable. Close to everything and it certainly helped that the weather was spectacular! Will definitely go back another time!"

"We had such a magical long weekend at Elle’s home in Shelter Island. The house is prettier and more spacious than the photos. The open plan living room, kitchen, dining area is spacious and airy and goes straight out to a lovely deck with beautiful water views. There’s plenty of room and bedrooms are all great. It’s such a lovely, quiet, peaceful home and in a really quiet area of Shelter Island. The walk to Shell Beach is awesome. And there is beach access a few minutes walk from the house....

"Nice property set up nicely for a family with children."

"We are repeat vacationers to this wonderful, spacious, clean, well loved home. Eight family members (and our 7yo Portuguese Water

) stayed comfortably enjoying the pool, grill, and well appointed kitchen -Steve is a very communicative and generous owner and is able to answer any question about the house or island readily - We hope to be back again for summer vacation! Thanks Steve!"

"We stayed at this cottage over Thanksgiving weekend. Loved the living room with lots of light. The beds were comfortable and everything was sparkling clean. The owner, Leslie, was easy to work with and responded immediately to any questions I had. We will stay at this house again on our next visit."