Find all hotels by Red Roof Inn in Garwood, NJ from SAR 313

"The room was tight and not very clean, especially for over $300 for 1 night. We booked a king and received 2 double beds. Hotel staff just wanted to get done so didn't provide information about amenities or anything else. I wouldn't bother to stay there again."

"Housekeeping staff was great and did a good job everyday but the person we first met on arriving was rude. We understand rooms may not be available for early check in but the same can be conveyed in a kind manner. We reached early so they gave us access to a common guest washroom which was terribly dirty and started the trip on a bad note. "

"The hospitality here was top notch. I was given cookies and water upon entry and Kevin at the front desk was the nicest. The bellman was also very helpful and had suggestions for travel logistics. The room was very clean (when staying in the Times Square area, do not expect a huge room) and the room had everything I needed to feel comfortable and safe for the night. Within blocks of subway stations and travel was convenient, though I do suggest planning out your travel routes ahead of booking if you have luggage. Would recommend!"

"The shower on had 1/2 of a shower door, and we did not have enough towels to soak up the water on the floor, but they did send us plenty more towels right away for the next 4 nights, and the elevators were absolutely the slowest I have ever seen in my life , it even came to the point that my wife and went up to 3 rd floor by escalators the walk the stairs to the 7 th Floor to catch one of the elevators that would stop there and only go up. I will say that all the employees there are absolutely excellent, helpful and courteous, everyone there were extremely helpfull ."

"Very clean room! They give cans of water when they clean your room which was a rice perk. Toiletries smelled very nice as well. "

"Micro rooms are clean and all you need in NYC. The sheets are a bit ruff; otherwise, all good."

" Nice hotel"

"Family of 3- room was exactly what we expected. Location was great! We love to utilize the subway and this hotel was close to 3 different transit lines which made it super easy for us to navigate and get anywhere we needed to be in Manhattan. Loved being able to walk to Staten Island Ferry, Wall Street, Battery Park, and loads of local eateries like Liberty Bagel and Tacombi. We loved being able to have somewhere safe to keep our luggage before we checked in and after check out so we could continue to explore NYC. All the staff were lovely and the hotel was impeccably clean."

"The stay had a bit of a mixed experience. Check-in started off with a very long line, which was frustrating at first, but once an additional associate stepped in, things moved along much faster and more efficiently. Unfortunately, the atmosphere during the evening wasn’t as pleasant. A guest from the room next to ours—who appeared to have had quite a bit to drink—was at the bar loudly complaining that it wasn’t happy hour and repeatedly claimed we were being too loud. Despite her behavior, we were the ones approached and warned about noise, which felt a bit unfair given the situation. We tried to be accommodating and even asked if we could relocate to the lobby sitting area, and were initially told that would be fine. However, once the night shift associate came on, we were told we could no longer sit there and would need to go outside instead. Considering it was about 40 degrees, that wasn’t a reasonable option. Overall, the inconsistency in communication and handling of the situation made for a frustrating experience. If you’re considering traveling with a group and hope to spend time together at the hotel, I would steer away from this one, as that doesn’t seem to be something they accommodate or encourage. "