The Best Hotels Closest to Fire Island Lighthouse in Bay Shore for 2026

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

Tonight

Tomorrow

This weekend

Next weekend

Our top choices for Fire Island Lighthouse hotels

A marina entrance with a sign for Seaborn Marina Weigh Station, boats docked, and a large shark sculpture above.

1. The Ocean Bay House

9.6 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Elizabeth

SAR 1,565 total

includes taxes & fees

10 Nov - 11 Nov

A backyard with a dense lavender plant, wooden chairs, and a wooden deck.

2. Come As You Are Inn

16.2 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

luiz claudio

SAR 965 total

includes taxes & fees

10 Nov - 11 Nov

An outdoor bar area with seating and a fire feature, surrounded by a building with multiple floors and large windows.

3. Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

14.8 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Amanda

SAR 617 total

includes taxes & fees

22 Nov - 23 Nov

A modern building entrance with a bench, potted plants, and a blue mat leading to a reception area.

4. Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island

19.5 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Alberto

SAR 502 total

includes taxes & fees

2 Dec - 3 Dec

An indoor swimming pool with clear glass walls, a tiled floor, and a few chairs near the windows.

5. Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia

19.7 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Phil

SAR 536 total

includes taxes & fees

22 Nov - 23 Nov

An outdoor patio area with a stone fire pit surrounded by sofas and chairs, string lights overhead, and a view of a multi-story building in the background.

6. Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

14.8 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Anne Patricia

SAR 637 total

includes taxes & fees

22 Nov - 23 Nov

A spacious living room with a fireplace, large windows, and a modern chandelier.

7. Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport

19 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Yolanda

SAR 597 total

includes taxes & fees

3 Dec - 4 Dec

A hotel with a prominent sign, a covered entrance, and a car parked in front.

8. La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport

19.4 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Alberto

SAR 381 total

includes taxes & fees

30 Nov - 1 Dec

A hotel room with a large bed, a sofa, a small table, and a framed picture on the wall.

9. Best Western Bar Harbour Inn

19.8 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Dave

SAR 613 total

includes taxes & fees

1 Dec - 2 Dec

A spacious lobby with a large window, a sofa, a chair, a small table, and a reception desk.

10. Rodeway Inn Macarthur Airport

18.7 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Virginia A

SAR 397 total

includes taxes & fees

3 Dec - 4 Dec

A beach with a house and a pier in the background.

11. Super 8 by Wyndham Lindenhurst

13.1 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Christopher M

SAR 566 total

includes taxes & fees

10 Nov - 11 Nov

A café named 'CAFE PRONTO' with a counter and seating area.

12. Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island

19.7 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Franck

SAR 525 total

includes taxes & fees

15 Nov - 16 Nov

A modern kitchen with a marble countertop, a coffee machine, and a refrigerator.

13. Red Roof Inn Copiague

16.4 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Kherani

SAR 489 total

includes taxes & fees

16 Nov - 17 Nov

A spacious lobby with modern furniture, large abstract paintings, and a flat-screen TV mounted on the wall.

14. Clarion Hotel & Conference Center Ronkonkoma MacArthur Airport

19.3 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

William Flood

SAR 432 total

includes taxes & fees

8 Nov - 9 Nov

A bar area with a counter, bar stools, and a television screen.

15. Deer Park Motor Inn

16.2 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Junxin

SAR 472 total

includes taxes & fees

17 Nov - 18 Nov

A white shelving unit with decorative items, including a mixtape box, two golden bird figurines, and three glass vases.

16. Sundown Escape-South Shore Long Island

12.1 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Samantha

SAR 1,125 total

includes taxes & fees

18 Nov - 19 Nov

A calm river with a white fence and a car parked by the riverbank.

17. South Bay Motel

14.9 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Shelton

SAR 600 total

includes taxes & fees

5 Nov - 6 Nov

A bedroom with a bed, a bedside table, a chair, and a heater.

18. LINDENHURST MOTEL

13.5 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

Danielle

SAR 575 total

includes taxes & fees

5 Nov - 6 Nov

A wooden deck with a white railing, a stone pathway, and a white fence in the background.

19. Spacious 3BR Family Home Near Everything

17.8 km from Fire Island Lighthouse

SAR 1,193 total

includes taxes & fees

17 Nov - 18 Nov

View all properties

Compare popular hotels close to Fire Island Lighthouse

Property	Property class	Guest rating
The Ocean Bay House	3.5 star property	10.0 Exceptional 117 reviews	View
Come As You Are Inn	2.0 star property	10.0 Exceptional 73 reviews	View
Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex	3.0 star property	8.8 Excellent 1,000 reviews	View
Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island	2.5 star property	8.4 Very good 1,662 reviews	View
Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia	2.5 star property	8.6 Excellent 1,200 reviews	View

Other attractions near Fire Island Lighthouse

A tall grass plant with a sun shining in the background.

Lighthouse Beach

9.0/10 (2 reviews)

If a restful vacation is part of your travel plans, Lighthouse Beach might be the perfect place to seek out during your trip to Bay Shore. While you're in the area, stroll along the marina.

See properties

Top Fire Island Lighthouse Hotel Reviews

The Ocean Bay House

Bay Shore

10/10 Excellent

Ronald A

Come As You Are Inn

Sayville

10/10 Excellent

Our first and hopefully not our last stay at the Come As You Are Inn was a wonderful experience. Mark and Ari provide a welcoming and accomodating space within which one feels at home . The accomodations are delightful . The breakfasts , including freshly baked goodies are just right to start the day. Topping it all off , we enjoyed the opportunity to engage in extended conversations with Mark and Ari exploring a myriad of topics. A rarity in todays world. If you are looking for something more...

Laura

A modern bar area with a marble island, bar stools, and a large selection of bottles and glasses.

Residence Inn by Marriott Melville

Melville

10/10 Excellent

Karen

An outdoor patio with a pool, white furniture, and a fire pit.

Hampton Inn & Suites By Hilton Long Island Farmingdale

Farmingdale

10/10 Excellent

Lizbeth

Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

Central Islip

10/10 Excellent

First time we had stayed at this facility. Front desk staff was outstanding and took action to make us feel very welcome. Maid service could have been better since they only came in 2 of the four days that we were guests. Had to ask the front desk for a replacement for the tissue box. Front desk folks (Irene Reyes especially) went out of their way to make us feel welcome and secure a wheelchair for my wife during the entire stay. Thought the pricing was a little steep but it was...

Anonymous traveler

A modern kitchen with a breakfast bar, waffle station, and various food items displayed.

Hampton Inn Long Island / Commack

Commack

10/10 Excellent

WILLIAM

Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport

Ronkonkoma

10/10 Excellent

Yolanda

Sundown Escape-South Shore Long Island

Bay Shore

10/10 Excellent

Samantha

An indoor swimming pool with clear blue water, surrounded by lounge chairs and tables.

Homewood Suites by Hilton Ronkonkoma

Ronkonkoma

10/10 Excellent

Anonymous traveler

Two twin beds with white bedding, wooden headboards, bedside tables with lamps, and a window with curtains.

Whitman Motor Lodge

Huntington Station

10/10 Excellent

Maria

A group of people toasting with wine glasses at a table.

Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Hauppauge

Hauppauge

10/10 Excellent

Anonymous traveler

An outdoor patio area with wicker furniture, a central fire feature, and string lights.

Hilton Garden Inn Melville

Plainview

10/10 Excellent

Margaret

A large, historic building with a symmetrical garden featuring geometrically shaped ponds and neatly trimmed hedges.

Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate

Huntington

10/10 Excellent

M

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the area like around Fire Island Lighthouse?

Fire Island Lighthouse is located in a welcoming area of Bay Shore known for its beautiful island views. If you're looking for a convenient place to stay, check out the 11 hotels and other accommodations you'll find within a mile.

How many hotels will I be able to find near Fire Island Lighthouse?

Expedia has 11 hotels and other accommodations within a mile from Fire Island Lighthouse.

If I need to cancel the hotel reservation for my stay near Fire Island Lighthouse, will I receive a refund?

Yes, most hotel bookings are refundable if you cancel prior to the hotel's cancellation deadline, which in most cases is within 24 or 48 hours of check in. If your reservation is non-refundable, you might still have the option to cancel and receive a refund within 24 hours of your booking. Plug in your dates, click on "Search", then you can filter by "fully refundable" to view the best options available near Fire Island Lighthouse.

Where can I learn more about changing or cancelling my trip in the area near Fire Island Lighthouse?

To find more details about updating your stay near Fire Island Lighthouse or cancelling it, click here.

What can I see and do near Fire Island Lighthouse?

Dip your toes in the water at Robert Moses Beach, Ocean Beach, and Lighthouse Beach. Surround yourself with nature at Atlantique Beach, Richard L. Brooks Memorial Park, and Oak Beach. You might plan a visit to Captree State Park or Robert Moses State Park while you're in the area.

Find hotels near Fire Island Lighthouse, Bay Shore from SAR 333

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Filter by

Property class

Guest rating

Our top choices for Fire Island Lighthouse hotels

1. The Ocean Bay House

2. Come As You Are Inn

3. Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

4. Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island

5. Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia

6. Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

7. Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport

8. La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport

9. Best Western Bar Harbour Inn

10. Rodeway Inn Macarthur Airport

11. Super 8 by Wyndham Lindenhurst

12. Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island

13. Red Roof Inn Copiague

14. Clarion Hotel & Conference Center Ronkonkoma MacArthur Airport

15. Deer Park Motor Inn

16. Sundown Escape-South Shore Long Island

17. South Bay Motel

18. LINDENHURST MOTEL

19. Spacious 3BR Family Home Near Everything

Compare popular hotels close to Fire Island Lighthouse

Other attractions near Fire Island Lighthouse

Lighthouse Beach

Top Fire Island Lighthouse Hotel Reviews

The Ocean Bay House

10/10 Excellent

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the area like around Fire Island Lighthouse?

How many hotels will I be able to find near Fire Island Lighthouse?

If I need to cancel the hotel reservation for my stay near Fire Island Lighthouse, will I receive a refund?

Where can I learn more about changing or cancelling my trip in the area near Fire Island Lighthouse?

What can I see and do near Fire Island Lighthouse?