Find all hotels by Premier Resorts in Starr Island
Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check prices for these dates
Tonight
9 Oct - 10 OctTomorrow
10 Oct - 11 OctThis weekend
9 Oct - 11 OctNext weekend
16 Oct - 18 Oct
Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in
Top Starr Island Hotel Reviews
Sherwood Inn
8/10 Good
"The staff were very helpful and friendly. The grounds were beautiful. We weren’t able to use the outdoor amenities as it was October. The room was comfortable but a little dated, the carpet needed replacing in the room we were in but it didn’t make the stay at all uncomfortable. We would recommend this resort and would stay again."
Classic Muskoka Getaway - Hot Tub, Private Beach, Firepit & View!
10/10 Excellent
"We had such a wonderful stay at this beautiful Muskoka cottage! From the moment we arrived, everything was clean, comfortable, and thoughtfully prepared. The cottage had absolutely everything we needed for a relaxing and enjoyable getaway — the kitchen was well equipped, the rooms were comfortable, and all the amenities were exactly as described.The cleanliness really stood out to us. Everything was spotless and very well maintained, which made us feel right at home. The host was also incredibly thoughtful and organized. She provided a detailed file that perfectly explained everything we needed to know about the cottage, including the amenities and instructions, which made the entire stay feel effortless and truly relaxing. We never had to worry about figuring things out or wondering where anything was.The location was perfect for enjoying everything Muskoka has to offer while still having a peaceful and private place to come back to. You can really tell that the host puts a lot of care into making sure her guests have a comfortable and enjoyable experience.We truly loved our stay and would absolutely come back again. Highly recommend this cottage to anyone looking for a beautiful, clean, well-equipped, and relaxing Muskoka getaway! "
Christie's Mill Inn & Spa
10/10 Excellent
"Had a fantastic time with my teenage daughters. Hope to return soon."
Muskoka - The Hummingbird Tea Lake cabin
10/10 Excellent
"Absolutely fantastic place. Great nature. Great fishing. Cottage is well maintained. Thank you for the canoes and life jackets."
Severn Lodge
10/10 Excellent
"Great experience. Enjoyed the freshly made breakfast"
Cottage on water (waterfront)
10/10 Excellent
"A great spot for either a quiet getaway from city living or a family gathering near the water. Lots of outdoor adventures to choose from in surrounding towns and villages."
Muskoka - The Eagle's Nest
10/10 Excellent
"Great location!"
Spacious -Custom Build Lakehouse-strtt-2026-127
10/10 Excellent
"AMAZING VACATION, Highly recommend.All the cottages I have been to have tons of Mosquitos and this cottage has almost no Mosquitos.VERY Spacious cottage with big bedrooms and cathedral Ceiling, with 3 king beds2 Queen 1 single and 1 Pull out coach it allows up to 13 people to sleep over.The kitchen is very well equipped, and everything was in good working order.We really enjoyed all the amenities and well equipped …board games, Babington/volleyball net, canoe, bikes, spa. Ideal garden for relaxing and for the kids to play. Rocky beach across the street to go for a swim. Lots of sandy beaches are also easily accessible. Parking Passes for the Awenda park, a few minutes by car from the house, are available to enjoy it for free."
Newly renovated family cottage on Georgian Bay steps from Honey Harbour
10/10 Excellent
"Rest and relaxation at its best"