Find Beach Hotels in Shelter Island, NY

"Great"

"We always have a great stay at Aqualina. Can’t wait to come back next year. Thank you to all the staff. "

"The water views of the Sound were spectacular & were accessible for every meal. The staff was friendly & accommodating -- they had lots of good meal recommendations both in house & for outside restaurants. This inn had a very peaceful vibe -- would definitely return!"

"The room was very nice and the staff were all very helpful. The only small negatives were the TV was mounted at an angle and the bathroom countertops were very low"

"Beachcomber was perfect! We had a blast and will definitely stay here again"

"We really enjoyed the location. It was perfect for us with a toddler. Had a lot of fun in the pool and enjoyed the surrounding restaurants and aquarium. The room was comfortable and clean. The Riverwalk behind the hotel is a beautiful walk to end the day. "

"hotel was amazing!!!! restaurant not so great, very expensive and little options but it is very close (7 min walk) to town, so that is not a problem if you want to walk to get dinner or lunch"

"The hotel is lovely. By their own admission the owners have a notice saying excuse us whilst we renovate. The lodge was fine, we didn’t really notice it wanted much done. The car park was plenty, the room was spacious and comfy. Great views out the back. Convenient for the area, we really liked it. "

"We loved 45 min boat ride with amazing captain Paul! Properly is stunning with friendly staff. It’s my second year staying at MYC and never get disappointed! We are coming back soon . "