Find hotels near San Pablo Catholic Church, Marathon from SAR 286

"We loved our stay here. All of the employees are super-friendly and helpful. They go above and beyond to make sure everything is perfect. The hotel itself is very clean and housekeeping does a wonderful job keeping it that way. A shout out to John, Donna, Louis and many others that went out of their way for us. Highly recommend!!"

"We had a great experience staying. From the receptionist at the check in. She checked us in early and upgraded us too. The facility was very clean and the breakfast was on point. The restaurant next door was also a 10 out of 10 because the food was good as well as the service. Over all experience was great. "

"It was a beautiful spacious and so clean they let us check in 3 hours early"

"The cabin was unique and perfect for someone who isn't planning to spend a long time inside on a vacation to the Keys. We traveled with a 5 year old and a 2 year old and they were able to sleep comfortably in the bunk beds. They LOVED seeing Blaze the local dog every day. They couldn't wait to see him and pet him when they woke up each day. We were able to use the kayaks to explore the bay and even saw two eagle rays feeding in the currrent. WARNING: if you are planning to kayak, be careful going under the Sadowski Causeway. The current was VERY strong and it was very difficult to steer and propel the larger two person kayaks back against that current. We thoroughly enjoyed the swimming pool and planned to play some pickle ball but we ran short on days/time. The staff was very friendly and the door to the office was always open if we had questions. We did laundry there and they were able to exchange for coins which was very helpful. The only minor issues we had were related to the bunk bed room and the temperature it reached overnight. We left the fan running but there is no A/C blowing in that room, so if you closed the door, the kids would get very hot overnight and wake up sweating. We solved this problem by leaving the living room A/C running and opening their door while closing the door to the separate bedroom that the adults stayed in. The bicycles on site were not in the best shape and the helmets were also pretty worn. Overall, a great place to stay!"

"Thanks Brian for letting us stay at your house. We have a really great time. Excellent house. Very nice and clean. Great communication with the owner. We look forward to coming back soon!!"

"Great views, clean and comfortable. Especially liked the elevator. Only downside was the stovetop was difficult to control. It was either barely on or full blastThe property manager was awesome. One of the a/c units was having trouble keeping up. So he came by and put in a temporary unit that solved the issue"

"All the “this place is a gem” reviews are right! Clean, well-built, very accommodating place. The location is also perfectly central to all that the Keys have to offer, and it’s a lot. The next time we come back to the Keys, we will just search straight for this place. 10 stars!"

"We stay in the Keys every summer, and the Sailfish House is by far the best rental we've ever booked. The home is absolutely beautiful, incredibly well-maintained, and had everything we could possibly need for a perfect stay. The attention to detail is unmatched — even the kitchen knives were sharpened, which seems small but speaks volumes compared to other rentals we've stayed in.Chris from maintenance was fantastic and super helpful, especially with showing us how to use the dock whips. Meredith was also amazing to work with — this is actually the second property we've rented through her, and just like the first time, she was wonderful, responsive, and made the entire process seamless.For the first time ever, we are already seriously considering booking the same home for next year. Sailfish House truly exceeded our expectations in every way. Highly, highly recommend!"

"Property was very clean, in good shape and well appointed. Highly recommended!"