Find all hotels by Independent in Oyster Bay, NY

"It was great"

"Convenient and SAFE parking. Staff was very helpful. 15 minute walk to Yankee Stadium. This is our go to place to stay when coming to NY to watch baseball."

"Excellent hotel within 20 mins of Laguardia airport. Free shuttle included. Clean, staff was great!"

"Very nice and clean place helpful workers with smile "

"Was shown 2 rooms, but terrible and smelled even worse, tv was not working, towels are thin and completely worn out. The bed spread had burn holes everywhere, the bathroom was filthy and the pillows were like pancakes. To add insult to injury, I was awoken at 3:30am by a man banging on the door for nearly 20 minutes screaming, I called the desk and there was no answer; the man started banging on the door again and again I called the desk and this time someone picked up, when I asked why is there a stranger banging down the door, the response was “he’s drunk and looking for the women that stood there yesterday” needless to say I had a crappy night at this dump. This place needs to be closed down."

"Nicer hotel for the area…staff very helpful and provided great customer service. The gym and restaurant on site were convenient and easy to utilize and the restaurant atmosphere was nice and service great. As most NYC Hotels, the rooms, even the larger Studio Suite, are not large. However, the room was clean, uncluttered and included a safe and lil fridge. Parking….if ya bring a car, you gotta park in one of the 2 parking garages in the block the hotel is in. 1 gets busy and on a Friday night it maybe full. The 2nd one was available, until the elevator broke….only addressing this as the amenities Valet Parking…which there isn’t. Would definitely stay here again if I needed an Uptown hotel."

"The staff is always very helpful and the rooms are clean and comfortable"

"let me start with the airport shuttle, waited for almost 45 min after calling the property . Staff at check in was polite and helpful , however during checked out when needed some small change for tips. the staff at the counter was every unprofessional by showing the attitude. Room is clean but the mattress is old and sank in and edge of the bed curve out. Need replacement. carpet at the coridor is dirty. The only restaurant at the hotel need improvement , besides pizza , nothing is presentable at all. way way to salty. to be frank, i was pretty disappointment with this one, not the standard of DOUBLE tree i am use to ."

"I had a comfortably, safe stay at melrose."