Find hotels near Key Cay, Great Harbour from SAR 645

"Excellent stay. Justin (owner/manager) is responsive and super helpful. Ann, who has worked here over 30 years is a gem. Ocean and beachfront. Quiet and spectacular!Thank you!"

"Gayle was a great host and was very helpful with our many questions before arrival. She was also on the property during our stay and was very friendly and helpful with anything we asked.Ivet, who was our main contact at the home, was terrific. On arrival, one of the members of our party had an injury on the ferry that needed some minor emergency room care and Ivet arranged to have a taxi pick us up at the hospital and bring us to the house, which was so appreciated as we were not released until after nine PM and we would have had difficulty obtaining a taxi and finding our way.Ivet also cooked dinner that night for our group, which was delicious, and stayed at the house until our group from the hospital returned.Ivet also checked in many times during our stay to make sure we had everything we needed and provided clean towels and tidied up the house.She also does great massages!The property was lovely, inside and out. We were able to swim in the ocean right from the property and the outside decks provided plenty of space in which to relax.The house was equipped with plenty of dish ware, glasses and kitchen supplies.We thoroughly enjoyed our trip."

"Room was very clean, and spacious. Balcony area had plenty of room for two, or even more . We ate breakfast at the restaurant every day, food was good, and reasonably priced"

"Always a great place to stay when you are using the Nanny Cay marina"

"Our suite was spotless, extremely spacious with good kitchen facilities and we really could not fault it. The balcony overlooking the sea was beautifully furnished with amazing sunset views. The staff were very helpful and pleasant. It was altogether a wonderful experience. We shall certainly return."

"Staff was fantastic and accommodating. "

"Trip was amazing. This is a small resort that has incredible rooms, restaurants, and a private beach. The staff was attentive, friendly, and always ready to help. The manager, Andrea, was very helpful and always was ready to do whatever we needed to make our stay great. The main restaurant had amazing food and outstanding service. The beachfront restaurant was a little more casual but food and service was great as well. Eating breakfast on the beach was relaxing. Carlos at the bar was friendly and good with the drinks. The resort is remote and not in a busy area, while this is wonderfully relaxing it does mean that there is very little within walking distance. There are a couple of restaurants within walking distance, if you need to go to the store or to another restaurant you'll need a taxi. The hotel is always glad to help you book one and the cab drivers were all fun and happy to talk about the island. If you're looking for a relaxing trip to the beach, with beautiful views, amazing staff, away from crowds, and top tier food you won't go wrong with the Sugar Mill. "

"Clean. Friendly staff. "

"The staff was very friendly and helpful. Convenient location. Pretty natural setting."