Find all hotels by Independent in Stillwater, OH

"This cottage is my new "home away from home"!! Everything was better than what you see in the pictures. The peacefulness and privacy of the area made me feel so relaxed. Morning coffee in the rocking chair on the porch while listening to the birds chirp set the mood for each day. Location to Amish / local establishments was easy to navigate once you know the area. Melissa was quick to respond to any needs, yet very respectful of my wish for independence. I have - and will continue to highly recommend this cottage for a destination near Sugar Creek or New Philadephia, Ohio"

"Cheap prices. Not happy with being woken up by housekeeping banging on my door at 0630. And to find out she was banging on the wrong door. "

"The staff were FANTASTIC. Breakfast was really good. Didnt get to enjoy pool/hot tub. The room cleanliness was a bit lacking but staff jumped right in to rectify the situation by offering a room change."

"Clean, friendly staff overall great day"

"Very clean and staff very attentive "

"Did not have breakfast but did have great coffee. Room was very nice and clean. Liked the firm/soft pillow options on each bed. Great location for the hotel. We were there just for overnight but had a very restful sleep. "

"Breakfast was okay and the hot tub felt amazing but the jets weren’t very strong!!"

"There was mold in the refrigerator and the a/c heat unit was falling apart"

"We had everything we needed and more. They went above and beyond for their guests. We will definitely be back. It was quiet and relaxing and beautifully decorated. Very cozy and homey. "