Find all hotels by Independent in Shirley, NY from SAR 523

"The only thing I did not like was the sandwich purchased at Cuppa, it was chicken salad on a croissant with tomato and lettuce, there was more lettuce and tomato than chicken salad, croissant was rubbery.. coffee was good should have a lid on top that the coffee will not spill out., in other words like a little lid ."

"Our stay was terrific. The room was comfortable and affordable. My daughter loved the pool and game room. The location was ideal for what we intended to do while on LI."

"Staff super friendly, room clean and spacious."

"Clean, friendly staff, room was very nice. Safe area to stay in and having the Sanoma Grill attached was very nice to be able to walk into it from the Homiday Inn. Coffee station very nice and water with lemon in the front lobby "

"Convenient location. Very comfortable "

"Clean rooms, friendly staff. Good ambiance in lobby "

"The road leading to this hotel feels like a back ally, but any concerns you would have are put to rest when you get to the parking lot. Not that I was concerned personally because my family knows the area well, but I just wanted to put that out there for a first-time visitor. Having said all that, the staff was professional and accommodating. The hotel is clean and comfortable. They have a coffee machine that makes really good coffee. Not a joke. Really good coffee. And it’s on 24/7. The one thing that this property could look into is the speed of the elevators. My goodness they are slow. But that’s certainly not a huge deal. Overall, great place to stay. If I need to stay on this part of Long Island again, I won’t even look around, this is where I will be staying. "

"So close to wonderful farms for picking your own fruits Good access both to the North and South Forks Very good pool Very good staff Restaurant Bistro 52 has the best chocolate chip cookies one suggestion-- get the quiet, closing gently toilet seats"

"It met my expectations! Place is newly renovated, the room was cozy, clean, smelled lovely, the bathroom was clean. Definitely recommend this place! "