Find all hotels by Independent in Shelter Island Heights, NY from SAR91

"Love this town and gurneys for decades "

"Overall, this was a very good experience. The room was clean, including the bed and the bathroom. Everything worked as expected, and there was plenty of hot water for showering. The TV and the WiFi worked well. It felt safe. The property is convenient to all mid-shoreline activities. It was very quiet except for one instance in which there was a family with an exuberant toddler staying in the room right above me; I notified the desk person and he took care of it right away. It's a good budget...

"Delightful in every way. Particularly impressed by the service—reception, work crew (who rescued my locket from the drain!), and wait staff—all very helpful, efficient, and kind. We enjoyed the heated indoor pool, lovely view, and tasteful decor in our room. Would love to stay again "

"Excellent visit, had everything we needed. Super clean, exceptionally comfortable. "

"Clean room "

"Excellant "

"We didn't have a table and chairs outside. We called the front desk and asked for them. They never came. We got our beach chairs out of our car to use."

"Super cute room with brand new features including a little kitchenette and nice shower details. Walkable to the ferry and great restaurants. Pool and separate sandy lounging area overlooking the bay was the low key vibe we were searching for to be away from the bustle of dowtown area. Rich & Ben took care of us and we plan on returning. Thank you!"

"Friendly and accommodating staff"

"Aqualina was such a relaxing and enjoyable experience for our family! Super clean and friendly staff. We will definitely be going back!!"