Search Guest Houses in Shelter Island Heights

"Room was good size. Great bathroom and amazing shower. Indoor heated pool with nice steam and sauna. And the restaurant was amazing. Best meatballs ever and I “try” to make good meatballs. "

"My family and I were visiting Southampton from Queens because I was graduating from my Graduate Program at Stony Brook University's Southampton campus. Upon stepping into the main office of the hotel, I was greeted warmly (I believe the gentleman's name is, Christian). He had a big smile on his face, was super present and kind. I felt welcomed right away. He asked if I needed any help with luggage, and I told him that I didn't, but he helped my family and I anyway. The complimentary bag of waters and snacks was such a great touch. The suite my family and I stayed in was clean, spacious, and welcoming! I will definitely return!"

"I loved the fact that they had a free EV charger for us to use. In that part of CT those chargers are hard to find and most hotels don't have them."

"On this trip, we stayed in the big king room, which was dynamite!!! Although we have in the past stayed in every other room, every room has been comfortable and great. They are all located right next to the pool and hot tub which we fully enjoyed. The staff is very friendly and made us feel as if we were at home.They’re consistent in making the grounds look immaculate and beautiful, especially at night when tiki torches are lit and there’s a fire pit to sit next to, with very chill music in the background. Just very romantic and relaxing. Restaurants and Shopping are all very close and walkable and safe no matter what time of day, just a wonderful getaway. although we only stayed for two nights due to some business on Long Island, we are returning again to this hotel for another few days, we cannot wait. Highly recommend. It has become a staple of our life when we are looking for a getaway."

"front desk was lovely !! "

"Room was clean and appeared to be recently renovated. "

"Perfect spot, you can walk to anything in minutes "

"This property is absolutely adorable! Blue and White sitting RIGHT ON THE OCEAN! We had our own little deck and then there is a long full deck for everyone to lie out in the sun. Beach is pristine and gorgeous! You can fall asleep listening to the waves. Walkable to downtown Montauk, little shops and restaurants. Only downside was the air conditiioning unit was really really loud. When it 'clicked on', it make so much noise. Need to replace and put in wall units that are super quiet. But, my Mom and I stayed her and loved it. Absolutely adorable! And, the location can NOT be beat! You will love it!"

"Loved the peacefulness and the view from the deck!! Great place!! Would absolutely return!! Sherry Hill"