Search Condo Resorts in Shelter Island Heights

"Very nice staff and clean. Excellent stay overall. Would recommend they open the gym to 24/7, as 8am open time is late for early risers. Also keep sanitation supplies in the gym to wipe down equipment."

"Lovely and clean property overall. We enjoyed our stay there, and the staff were excellent and accommodating. "

"They have a Peloton Bike in the gym with SPD clips. Major Plus!!!"

"I love this place. Next time I wish I could have a better view. I went there before the new rooms were added. Every time I went there, I stayed in the main building right upstairs from the check-in facing the water with my husband and I absolutely loved it. I was actually married there in the old ballroom. I was put in a room that I faced the side of the building and parking lot. I like it there because you can have your meals there if you want they should put a microwave in the rooms. I grew up there on the shore when I was a kid so it is a very pretty place. I think it’s understaffed. I saw the same woman there almost 3 shifts in a row. I think she was a manager. She was delivering drinks, which I thought was crazy and then I saw her the next morning at breakfast time being the hostess, I said to her, don’t you ever get a day off she said thank you for noticing. She was a very pleasant, nice woman, but I think it’s understaffed. I stayed there during the wrong time of year. It was spring break. Children were running up and down the hallway, which was not appropriate And they were with a parent. That’s what really got me - back in the day when I was a parent of young children, I would never let my children run up and down the hallways but times are different now -not for the better!!!"

"it was great. staff were super friendly an helpful. shuttle service was super convinient"

"We loved our two nights at Sag Habor and Baron's Cove was a perfect location with just the right facilities for our needs. Off season in the Spring must surely be the best time as there were enough visitors to make it interesting, but not too full. The bar and restaurant were excellent, with inside and outside space. All staff were professional and engaging, and could not have been better. The food was excellent. Our room was ideal, roomy enough, well decorated and very clean. Very much recommended hotel and the village of Sag Harbor. "

"The room was clean. The property was well kept. The town is a block away so you can walk to everything."

"This is a super elevated motel vibe. Area is janky but accommodations were excellent."

"Kenny isn't the Tipp, he's the Tops"