Search Cottages in Florida Keys

"Average stay with average views and limited amenities. Room was decent. Beach was quite small. On-site restaurant is pricey with average tasting food. "

"Great for a low key extended stay."

"I recently stayed at this hotel in Key Largo, and overall, it’s a mixed experience with some clear highlights. The biggest plus is how genuinely pet-friendly the property is. Not just “allowed,” but truly welcoming—something that’s rare and very appreciated. The atmosphere is incredibly peaceful and calm, perfect for disconnecting and unwinding. Valet parking is not only efficient, but the team is also genuinely kind and helpful—one of the standout aspects of the stay. That said, the property itself feels a bit worn. Not terrible, but definitely showing its age. The overall concept leans heavily toward a “do-it-yourself” experience: you need to pick up your own towels, get your own ice, and handle small things that you’d normally expect to be taken care of in a more full-service hotel. Another downside is the lack of guidance at check-in. No one really explains how the amenities work or what’s available—you’re essentially left to figure everything out on your own. Service overall is average. The staff is polite, but nothing stands out—no real sense of going above and beyond. The beach service, in particular, is almost nonexistent. If you’re expecting to order drinks or food while relaxing by the water, you’ll likely be disappointed. The restaurant is good—solid, enjoyable meals—but not particularly memorable. It does the job without trying to impress. For a stay that cost over $2,000 for three nights, you naturally expect a higher level of service and attention to detail."

"Nice"

"Everything about this location is excellent. One of the best experiences for me and the family. Stunning views and two pools to choose from. We definitely found a "must stay here" location in the keys. Front desk staff has always been professional, and accommodating. Susie helped our family out with staying an additional night because we loved the place that much. Thank you so veey much again!"

"Every aspect of our stay was awesome for our first time visiting The Keys. Everyone in the front office, to the people that maintained the property and guest rooms, and especially to the two gentlemen making made to order omelettes were wonderful. We loved our room and the view of the ocean was spectacular and with the most beautiful sunrises each morning. Starting the day with a delicious breakfast was wonderful. We very much enjoyed the beach, the hot tub and the pool. We drove down to Old Town and had a wonderful time before returning to our beautiful guest room. Can’t wait to visit again!!"

"Had a great stay, our second tone at this property. If have kids that want to play on the beach this Ain't the place. Water access is with stairs and during low tide its not very deep. For me and my wife just looking to relax, it was awesome"

"Such a beautiful property, but our room was tired, dark and need some updating! Ours had stained carpeting and felt very damp, like it hadn't been overhauled since the 80's. Everything was clean. Lots to do - great activities (fishing equipment/bait, kayaks, paddleboards, etc.), security, views, etc. Staff was friendly. Main areas and restaurants well maintained, as well as beaches. "

"My family has been going to Lime Tree Bay for about 40 years. It's where I got married in 2005. We had a nice stay there as always. Everyone was friendly, great amenities."