Search Cottages in Cottekill

"We did not have the breakfast but did try the dinner buffet and was told it was new to them but I definitely would not eat that again! They were very accommodating re heating the meal for us in the microwave but not worth $25 per person. They did remove the charge for us which was very helpful. We tipped the waiter just the same we knew it wasn't his fault he was great! Parking was tough because there was a banquet at the hotel but other than that we would love to come back because of the wonderful staff and our room was fantastic!"

"The only drawback of this hotel is the Storyteller restaurant and lounge. It's such a beautiful room but the options there are so limited if you want to just relax and have a drink or small bite in the afternoon. I was there with my family from 3pm - 5pm and we managed to get coffee and one iced tea but it was not as easy as you'd think for such a lovely room and bar."

"Comfortable bed, clean room, the only negative was the paint smell when we walked in. "

"Room was clean, simple, and quiet. Efficient check--in and check-out. Continental breakfast was a cut above the usual, with good-quality pastries and plenty of options. I would have liked an easy chair and reading lamp in my room, but otherwise it was a nice place to stay - a beautiful historic property. Will try the tavern next time."

"The staff was very courteous & friendly. The room was clean & the breakfast menu was great serving different options every morning. We will stay here again the next time we are in New Paltz."

"Staff super friendly and helpful Especially Andrea"

"The room was very clean and quiet"

"Nice enough place prices adequate"

"The breakfast menu was fresh and the coffee at all times was a nice perk. The staff at checkout was rude and even though we had asked for adjoining rooms, we were not provided that at check in. We were instead given rooms on opposite floors. There was something spilled on the side table and something on the bottom of the bathroom door. "