Find all hotels by onefinestay in Sag Harbor, NY

"Javier ( manager), Luisa (pool attendant) and staff were exceptional!!!! The accommodation and considerations were so great. We only stayed one night but aren’t leaving without booking another trip soon. Btw, the food for adults were fantastic, however nothing to accommodate the kids which was weird since the place is so kid friendly. "

"Beautiful hotel! All sharp and excellent condition - I loved the bed - sheets etc!"

"much improved inn from 2 years ago"

"Highly recommended "

"5 stars only thing is the pool closed early. It was very expensive for everything. Breakfast was not included and was overpriced for everything. We even had to rent tennis racquets for the courts."

"Property was clean and easy to stay at!"

"The breakfast and restaurant were great. The pool was very nice as well. I would come back."

"Great place to stay and very walkable to town. Also plenty of free parking."

"Great little gem in Southampton"