Find all hotels by Independent in Pigeon Island

"The room is outdated and disgusting. Mold in shower, dirt build up on shower door. Bedding or torn, blankets have bleach spot. I had a nose bleed and for days housekeeping refuse to changed duvet. I took duvet off and place in hallway and then they finally changed it. The staff lives on their cellphones, they don’t say hello, and they always look angry and unhappy. "

"Staff made the trip for me. They were so kind and welcoming! Would stay here again for sure!"

"Laundry service is great staff very courteous and professional"

"Shane was an incredible concierge and host! Seriously, he asked us our needs and delivered every time. All I hope is that our next time we cross paths with him again! Thank you for the wonderful stay!! "

"Friendliest employees I’ve met so far, very clean and the bar was stocked, air conditioning could be a little better in the rooms but overall 5 stars!!"

"Food was great and drinks were awesome!!"

"I highly recommend this resort—everything exceeded expectations. The beach was beautiful, the food was delicious, the rooms were spacious and comfortable, and the overall atmosphere was incredible. I truly have no complaints, just unforgettable memories!"

"Loved my time at BodyHoliday! The staff is incredibly friendly and ensured I had a great experience as a solo traveler. I am especially grateful for their scuba diving team and would highly recommend BodyHoliday for anyone looking to try scuba diving while on vacation! "

"I recently stayed at Secrets St. Lucia and unfortunately would not recommend this resort. The experience started off on the wrong foot with a very confusing check-in process that took nearly an hour. Throughout the stay, most of the staff came across as rude and disengaged, with a few notable exceptions—Sanchey, in particular, was wonderful and stood out for their kindness and professionalism. The rooms themselves were disappointing. They felt dirty and not well-maintained, although I will say the bed was comfortable and the shower had great water pressure and plenty of hot water. The food was another major letdown—bland, overly salted, and generally uninspired across the board. It felt like very little thought or care went into the dining experience. Lastly, the events and entertainment felt poorly executed—more childish than engaging, and overall thrown together without much attention to quality. For the price, I expected a much higher level of service and overall experience. I left feeling very unsatisfied—especially after a manager argued with me when I tried to provide feedback, which only added to the disappointment. Overall, this was not the level of experience I expected, and I wouldn’t choose to stay here again."