Search Cottages in Mystery Bay

"Relaxing days beside the water in “ quirky “ accommodation. Close to eateries. Great holiday spot."

"Very comfortable, well stocked with everything we needed, beautiful views, quiet"

"My partner and I had a wonderful holiday here. Sitting on the porch watching the beautiful birds, walking to the stunning beach, and the best sleep in comfy beds. Our car broke down and Eveleigh our host was so kind and helpful, and the neighbours were so welcoming they even took me to town to get supplies. We didn't want to leave. We can't wait to go back. Thanks Eveleigh for being a super host."

"Our experience was thoroughly positive. Happy to recommend this property highly."

"Absolutely beautiful stay. Perfect location if you want to explore Tilba Tilba. Be sure to take a tour of the gardens. The pond is magical."

"Hand feeding the rosella’s with the bird seeds provided "

"Fantastic accommodation in every respect. Immaculately clean, well equipped and comfortable with a great layout including large deck with waterviews. Very convenient location within easy walking distance to Blue Pool, main beach, hotel, Woolworths and local shops. We had Blue Cottage 2."

"One of the best pet friendly places we've ever stayed at. The garden is beautiful and the pet friendly section is both secure and spacious. Lyn and Robert were great hosts. We are definitely planning to stay here again."

"Great accomodation. Boat in front yard was a bit of a let down made the place look less attractive. Driveway down the side was narrow but just fitted our boat. If the house next door had people living in it it would have been hard as we could leave our boat and car up middle driveway and with the owners old boat in front yard we wouldn’t have been able to park there either. Overall good accommodation though"

"Great place to stay. Great location. Walk to everything, just a short stroll. Perfect for us."

"We are stunned by the property’s access to nature. The lake is in front while you can see cows, chooks, kangaroos, oyster farms, and also different kinds of birds. The cabin itself is just so cleaned and neatly arranged. Moreso, Justin is kind enough to let my kids try feeding the cows with her help. She is a very wonderful host. We were even able to cook the fresh eggs Justin gave us from the farm. It is such a beautiful place and highly recommendable. It is also just 5 mins away from the...

"A well kept and cosy little cottage with a fireplace and plenty of privacy. Very quiet area in very close proximity to local eateries, attractions and beaches- will definitely be visiting again in the summer!"

"We’ll definitely look into coming again as we really enjoy Bermagui, and will stay here again."

"Our family has just enjoyed a great getaway in Tilba. This was our first time visiting this area and we have left with such a memorable experience. The accommodation was amazing and comfortable for our family of 4. Sarah provided great hospitality offering recommendations that suited our family needs. The views were spectacular, and the kids enjoyed being amongst the animals. We look forward to visiting again soon and will recommend this stay to our family and friends."

"We thought the unit was the whole house but they are 2 units each colour. We were still happy with it though. Only thing we didn’t like was the shower nozzle was pointed to the side of the wall and couldn’t be adjusted so you had to rotate to get wet properly."

"Great location within walking distance from local restaurants and beaches. Nice accommodation for the family "

"This is a no-frills place that covered the basics. It's close to town and suitable for a couple or young family."

"The Seaview “Cottage” works really well for young families. Close proximity to the beach and pier make life a lot easier with little ones. Will definitely book again."

"My partner and I had a wonderful holiday here. Sitting on the porch watching the beautiful birds, walking to the stunning beach, and the best sleep in comfy beds. Our car broke down and Eveleigh our host was so kind and helpful, and the neighbours were so welcoming they even took me to town to get supplies. We didn't want to leave. We can't wait to go back. Thanks Eveleigh for being a super host."

"Absolutely perfect, a little slice of heaven. Only thing we would suggest is a small “manual” near the front door giving guidance on the fireplace etc."

"Great location and access to beach. However the cleanliness of the house was disappointing. Upon arrival we were offered a refund due to no wi-fi or second shower working. Upon opening up the house it was filled with a foul smell. The house cleaning needs improvement overall."