Find all hotels by Independent in Monticello, NY
Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check prices for these dates
Top Monticello Hotel Reviews
Hampton Inn Monticello
10/10 Excellent
"Very clean and spacious"
The Alder at Resorts World Catskills
10/10 Excellent
"Beautiful and excellent place"
Best Western Monticello
8/10 Good
"They had enough parking, the staff was helpful and friendly, the room was clean and ok"
Spacious Catskills Home with Covered Hot Tub
10/10 Excellent
"House had what we needed for our group and the hot tub was a nice bonus. Great and diverse book shelf as well!"
YO1 Longevity & Health Resorts, Catskills
10/10 Excellent
"Stay was amazing"
Sun Drenched Lakefront Cove
10/10 Excellent
"Clean property with great lake access. Garbage was full when we got there and the host didn’t know when it would be picked up. Turned out it was Thursday, which meant we left a full garbage can for the next people to come. The giant tv in the basement is a little strange as most of the seating is upstairs. We probably wouldn’t have noticed except the World Cup was on, and we couldn’t fit everyone comfortably in front of the big tv. Also, it was 70 extra for usable internet. The internet was so throttled that the upstairs tv would lag if the kids were using an iPad. (Downstairs tv was either hardwired or logged into the high speed WiFi.) That said, it was nice to unplug. Very poor cell reception so I usually just left my phone behind."
Lakefront Paradise: Views, Heated Pool, Games! Summer & Winter Fun For Everyone!
8/10 Good
"Ben is a very responsive host. Any problems directed to him, he resolved quickly, except for the pool. The description of the pool did not match the pool itself. It was not heated and not clean. Ben did indicate that someone would come to the house and take care of it, but no one did. We were given instructions to turn on the heater, but it did not work. We did have very hot weather, though, and that heated it nicely, but it remained green. There are only a few old, torn pool chairs and no umbrellas by the pool. Ben did say that if anything was lacking, to buy them, and he would reimburse us. We did buy a few umbrellas, but took them with us.The inside of the house is beautiful and clean. Bedrooms, beds, and bathrooms were very clean and comfortable. The downstairs accommodations did not include a double futon. The pullout sofa is old and uncomfortable. The other sofa was for one person. The Murphy bed is the most comfortable. Bathrooms did not include any toiletries, but the toilet paper was plentiful.The kitchen is grand with a very large refrigerator-freezer. It is well stocked with pots, pans, and cooking utensils. The dishwasher door needs repair, but we could get it closed. Also, there were not enough forks for everyone.Be careful walking on the back deck. It is old and splintery. The other decks are composite.The view is the main attraction of this house. The grounds and the house could use some TLC, but otherwise it accomodated us well."
Large Catskills Private Property. Sunset Estate! ❤️ 5 Star, Hottub, Island, ski
10/10 Excellent
"Clean house, good communication, and a great environment for your friends and family. Would definitely recommend if you are coming upstate!!"
Monticello Family Retreat. Pool, Firepit. 7min to casino. Sleeps 15
10/10 Excellent
"Perfect Repeat Stay for Our Crew!We booked this home again for our team of six and it has officially become our go-to spot in the area. Finding a property that comfortably accommodates a large crew is rare. The house was spotless, the amenities were top-notch, and the layout gave everyone their own space. The host makes check-in seamless, which is exactly what we need when traveling for business. We will absolutely be back again!"