Search Cottages in Medaryville

"Very comfortable room. If you like your hotel in a very quiet, countryside setting this is the place for you. Restaurants are are attached and don’t have to leave at all if you don’t want to. Great family setting."

"We had an amazing weekend at the lodge, it was private and we had more than enough space for 14 adults. The yard was perfect and the house was immaculate. I would recommend it to anyone!"

"Right off the highway easy to find great hotel! The staff is beyond friendly. The lady taking care of the breakfast was so kind and friendly to us. This is the 4th time staying at this hotel and we look forward to our next stay in a couple months! "

"This is the 2nd year we have gone there in the Summer. I am so happy that we found this place. It is tucked away in a little private corner without all of the traffic and noise. It is very cute and furnished with all you need. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND IT."

"This was an excellent stay!! Jim and Sue were very accommodating. The room was very clean and the housekeeping was top notch. This stay worked perfectly with my time I had to stay in Winamac. I highly recommend this place and will be returning next time I visit Winamac!!! Thanks guys for an excellent stay!!"

"This property worked well with our family group of 10. We had 5 adults; 4 teens and 1 10-year-old. 3 bedrooms for the adults; the media room with flexible futons for the teen girls; and another room with futons for the 2 guys (1 teen and 1 10-yr-old). We set up a folding table in the open kitchen for more dining space. The 3 bathrooms were great with plenty of towels for daily showers and plenty of hot water! Outdoor space was great with 2 docks, boat ramp, fire pit and much more. My husband's grandparents had a cottage on Lake Shafer when he was growing up and this place helped us create the same kind of memory-making opportunity in 2024 that my hubby had when he was a kid. We spent 1 day at Indiana Beach Amusement Park and would highly recommend! The host was very attentive and was quick to respond to questions. It was a great stay... and we would seriously consider a return visit!"

"This is the perfect house for a nice get away! Very cozy house right on the water with a beautiful view! Kathy is very friendly and accommodating! The house is supplied with everything you would need. 10/10 would rent here again!!"

"Came to the area to visit family and decided to try this cabin in lieu of a hotel room. Best choice ever! This cabin far exceeds any hotel in the Monticello area. It was just as described. Clean, well furnished and perfectly comfortable. Location was great; 10 minutes from the Kroger and Walmart. Lake view was nice and the deck was perfect for early mornings and evening for relaxing. Very quiet area of the lake. The sunroom was also perfect for when the weather was not suited for being outside. Overall… it was perfect for us and we will be back when we are in the area again."

"The property was incredible. Great location for the courses we were playing. The online photos don't do justice to how nice the house, and decks are."