Search Cabin Rentals in Herkimer

"Love this cute little cabin. A great spot off the road, cute fire pit area. Would definitely stay here again."

"This is our second time staying at the cabin, and we absolutely love it there! It is very relaxing and peaceful with beautiful views!"

"We were in town for a wedding. Property was beautiful and secluded… loved that it was off the beaten path. Saw tons of wildlife… bald eagle, deer 10ft off the deck. Very quiet setting."

"Great place to disconnect, especially if you have Verizon!! Nice spot to swim at the end of the road. Just needs some trails built into the 40 acres so you can explore it more easily. We stayed with our 4 kids, ages 11-17, they all had a blast and got off their electronics. Generator was easy to use for first timers so no worries there either."

"Very beautiful place and Emily was great and helpful"

"My husband and I enjoyed staying in this cabin. It's cute, clean, cozy and quiet. It was about 30 min from Cooperstown Dreams Park and past all of the people and tourists. Has everything you need (although a teeny tiny shower) and very calming!"

"This cabin is actually a large house with all the modern amenities you could ask for/need to make your stay comfortable. Beautiful inside and out, with extra touches that add to the memories you'll make here. Well worth the stay and would rent again if we come back to the area!"

"Perfect accommodations for our needs."

"My cousin and i enjoyed our stay. Very clean, comfortable beds, very well stocked kitchen. The front stairs were quite daunting! Getting to the front door with our bags took great effort. It did not diminish our enjoyment of the space but i would caution seniors (like us!) And anyone else with mobility or balance issues."

"The pictures do not lie! This place is absolutely beautiful! The property was clean and just perfect! The owner was responsive and a pleasure to deal with. I cannot wait to stay here again"

"Great cabin - clean, comfy beds and very quiet! Only complaint was the house water had an awful sulphur smell and we couldn’t drink it. Even taking showers & brushing teeth was unpleasant. Would suggest getting a whole house water filter and then the property would be 5 star!"

"We had a fantastic time at this property. Very comfortable setting, everything you need is right there. We stayed out by the fire pit deep into the night and were lucky enough to hear a great-horned owl in the distance. Really nice spot, super nice people, Especially Emily, very talented and charming host. We will be back!!"

"This house had everything you need for a great vacation! The staff at the resort was wonderful and we have already booked for next year! Definitely a hidden treasure!"

"Lovely stay at Henckley Reservoir. Emily & Kim(s) gave nice attention to detail like the waters and snacks available for excursions. We rented a pontoon boat and Andre was a great captain showing us around the lake first. Loved having a clean private beach to ourselves and the paddleboards and kayaks were easy to use. The view afternoon and evening was lovely including the loons. Thank you so much! Cabin was very comfortable and clean and up to date."

"We enjoyed a magical week of relaxation and restoration! Guest services staff were responsive and efficient. Looking forward to returning again!"