Find all hotels by Preferred in Fishers Island, NY from SAR 896

"Amazing restaurants at the hotel. Staff was friendly, accommodating, helpful. Casino was very clean, smoke free. Excellent shopping. Amazing spa. Just wish that Expedia would stop or clarify that the hotel stays are in the original part of the hotel and start offering stays in the updated rooms. I’m so tired of seeing the grand hotels then finding my rooms to be plainer and not the luxury room. Just add a note while we are looking at rooms. I’ll gladly pay more if I knew the room has been updated and not one of the original rooms. This happens all the time."

"The girl at the front desk was very helpful and pleasant and I appreciated being able to check in a little early"

"Didn’t get to stay the night had a family emergency had to leave an hour after I checked in. Hope to get credited for another stay in the future. Staff was very nice. "

"Always good, clean, new, breakfast is fine!"

"We spent 2 nights at the hotel. Were delighted to find out they had a free coffee bar in the mornings with both regular coffee and specialty coffees. Also, complimentary bottles of water. We also did not know they had a bar and bistro. The menu was limited but it was very convenient - breakfast for us. The exercise room had just 2 pieces of equipment and free weights. The pool was small and when we took a look, there was a workman repairing the rest room and he had the side door open which made the pool area chilly. Another plus, was the 3 EV charging stations. The staff were very helpful and friendly. Great place to stay."

"Our stay was just what we needed. Breakfast was full of choices and and plenty to eat and drink. A perfect stop in a lovely town."

"Excellent "

"Beautiful ! "

"Everything was very clean "