Find all hotels by La Quinta Inn & Suites in Fishers Island, NY from SAR 644

"Great place to stay. Rooms were big and clean. Breakfast was good. Outdoor area was nice to hang out. We were happy and would highly recommend. "

"Had a wonderful stay at the Hilton Mystic. Our room was obviously ready early but they charged us $25 to check in early. If room was obviously ready why the upcharge?"

"Lots to do even if you don’t gamble - pool great - tons of restaurants - beautiful room on high floor with scenic views "

"I have been coming to this hotel for the last 2 years. Few times a year. Very nice staff very convenient location and the pool is great! The coffee is really good too. I do wish there was a microwave in the room. "

"Nice place"

"Great place if u want a nice quite place to stay very close to all attractions "

"Would definitely stay there again!"

"Our stay was lovely. We had an Ocean view corner room which was a little far from where they put out chairs for the hotel residents, but we had our own. The service was excellent . The location of the Blue is excellent, no need to use a car when going into town."

"Spent a day at Misquamicut State Beach then had a great dinner at Buon Appetito across the street from the Hilltop. Hilltop was a wonderful, convenient and economical option for our day at the beach."