The Best Hotels Closest to Bay Street Theatre in Sag Harbor for 2026

Check prices for these dates

Tonight

Tomorrow

This weekend

Next weekend

Our top choices for Bay Street Theatre hotels

A spacious hallway with a fireplace, a large window, and a built-in shelving unit.

1. Sag Harbor Inn

0.6 km from Bay Street Theatre

Terri

SAR 939 total

includes taxes & fees

1 Nov - 2 Nov

A pool area with umbrellas, potted plants, and a pathway leading to a building.

2. Faraway Sag Harbor

0.5 km from Bay Street Theatre

Thomas

SAR 1,507 total

includes taxes & fees

17 Nov - 18 Nov

A beachside outdoor seating area with white Adirondack chairs and a fire pit.

3. Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

12.3 km from Bay Street Theatre

Gaurav

SAR 1,020 total

includes taxes & fees

1 Nov - 2 Nov

A modern bathroom with a large mirror, wooden vanity, and a sink. There is a chair and a small table in the adjacent living area, with a sofa and a view of the outdoors.

4. The Bentley Hotel Southampton

18.7 km from Bay Street Theatre

Armando

SAR 617 total

includes taxes & fees

10 Nov - 11 Nov

A modern outdoor seating area with two wicker chairs and a small table, overlooking a body of water and a wooden deck.

5. The Shoals Suites and Slips

12.3 km from Bay Street Theatre

Masayo

SAR 854 total

includes taxes & fees

29 Oct - 30 Oct

An outdoor dining area with a table and chairs, surrounded by tall trees and string lights.

6. A Room At The Beach

7 km from Bay Street Theatre

Annabel

SAR 1,270 total

includes taxes & fees

28 Oct - 29 Oct

7. East Hampton House Resort

11.3 km from Bay Street Theatre

Tina

SAR 722 total

includes taxes & fees

2 Nov - 3 Nov

A modern building with a wooden exterior, a balcony, and a pathway lined with potted plants and stepping stones.

8. Journey East Hampton

12 km from Bay Street Theatre

Erika

SAR 1,082 total

includes taxes & fees

2 Nov - 3 Nov

A bedroom with a wooden headboard, a bedside table with a lamp, and a bed with a grey blanket.

9. Bridgehampton Inn

7.6 km from Bay Street Theatre

Cori

SAR 1,282 total

includes taxes & fees

29 Oct - 30 Oct

A two-story house with a balcony, outdoor seating area, and a variety of plants.

10. Zey Hotel

12.6 km from Bay Street Theatre

sacha

SAR 660 total

includes taxes & fees

28 Oct - 29 Oct

A serene landscape with a calm body of water reflecting trees with autumn foliage.

11. House on Chase Creek

10.1 km from Bay Street Theatre

Tracey

SAR 793 total

includes taxes & fees

2 Nov - 3 Nov

A large, multi-story building with a porch and outdoor seating area, featuring multiple windows and a balcony.

12. The Chequit

10.4 km from Bay Street Theatre

Patrick

SAR 659 total

includes taxes & fees

23 Nov - 24 Nov

A living room with a fireplace, a television mounted above it, and a dining area in the background.

13. The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn

10 km from Bay Street Theatre

Lisa

SAR 2,065 total

includes taxes & fees

1 Nov - 2 Nov

Two bicycles with wicker baskets labeled "Sophie & Co." parked in front of a building with a dark door and white columns.

14. The Sagaponack

7 km from Bay Street Theatre

Jane

SAR 982 total

includes taxes & fees

28 Oct - 29 Oct

The entrance to The Harbor Front Inn with a double door and the address number 209.

15. The Harbor Front Inn

12.4 km from Bay Street Theatre

Antrii

SAR 672 total

includes taxes & fees

17 Nov - 18 Nov

A large, multi-story building with a swimming pool, outdoor seating, and a well-maintained garden.

16. East Hampton Art House Bed & Breakfast

12.6 km from Bay Street Theatre

IVAN

SAR 1,939 total

includes taxes & fees

2 Nov - 3 Nov

A large, white building with a green awning, surrounded by well-maintained lawns and colorful flower beds.

17. The Huntting Inn

10.2 km from Bay Street Theatre

Josie

SAR 1,573 total

includes taxes & fees

10 Nov - 11 Nov

A modern building with a pool, featuring a dining area with tables and chairs, and a glass entrance.

18. Topping Rose House

7.2 km from Bay Street Theatre

Adam

SAR 2,588 total

includes taxes & fees

10 Nov - 11 Nov

A house with a sloped roof, large windows, and a pathway leading to the entrance.

19. Mill House Inn

10.2 km from Bay Street Theatre

Rhett

SAR 1,763 total

includes taxes & fees

1 Nov - 2 Nov

A round outdoor table with a fire pit, two glass jars with grains, and a black grill.

20. The Roundtree, Amagansett

13.3 km from Bay Street Theatre

Dwight

SAR 2,384 total

includes taxes & fees

3 Nov - 4 Nov

View all properties

Compare popular hotels close to Bay Street Theatre

Property	Property class	Guest rating
Sag Harbor Inn	3.5 star property	9.4 Exceptional 681 reviews	View
Faraway Sag Harbor	4.0 star property	9.0 Wonderful 319 reviews	View
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows	4.0 star property	10.0 Exceptional 184 reviews	View
The Bentley Hotel Southampton	2.0 star property	9.6 Exceptional 607 reviews	View
The Shoals Suites and Slips	3.5 star property	9.4 Exceptional 348 reviews	View

Top Bay Street Theatre Hotel Reviews

The Sagaponack

10/10 Excellent

"Ok"

Faraway Sag Harbor

8/10 Good

"Beautiful and charming hotel! Unfortunately the restaurant was only serving breakfast and not dinner, since we arrived off- season. However the restaurant was freezing due to the heating system not working so we had to go elsewhere in town for breakfast. Too bad because it was a lovely room with a harbor view. Our biggest disappointment by far was the coffee in the room and in the lobby. Nasty stuff! I have never tasted coffee this bad in any hotel (and we have been to many). First of all at this high- end price point per night, Faraway should be providing at least a Nespresso machine in each room for a decent morning cup of coffee instead of instant coffee packets which went out with Sanka like forty years ago. :( Then we thought that maybe the coffee urns on the bar in the common area would at least provide a half decent cup of coffee. Boy were we wrong! The fact that other filled cups of coffee which were left on the bar still full told us that other guests felt the same about the quality of coffee. Thank goodness for Goldbergs Bagel shop in town! Come on guys. If you want to be recognized as a high end getaway in an extremely wealthy part of Long Island, please find yourselves a better quality coffee source. Its not that hard these days. We speak for all true coffee lovers."

Expansive Sag Harbor Estate with Pool, Tennis, Hot Tub, Close to Sag Harbor...

8/10 Good

"The house was perfect for our needs - accommodating our 3-generation family gathering. Older family members could stay on the main floor with minimal steps, everyone had plenty of privacy, and we really enjoyed the tennis courts and outdoor area. The open areas work well for a large group and there was enough seating for everyone. We had a great weekend and loved the private, quiet setting, too. Highly recommend!"

Escape to Sag Harbor

10/10 Excellent

"We really loved our stay as a three generation family! The home was clean, beautiful and really well-appointed for cooking and relaxing. There are three bedrooms, and the primary bedroom also had a set aside area with a curtain, which was a perfect place for our one year old to sleep. Our host was proactive in sending over helpful information and responded quickly to an inquiry. And, in my opinion the photos don't do the house justice in how beautiful and relaxing the space is. Bonus of the pool house which became our two older children's secret play room."

Other attractions near Bay Street Theatre

A harbor with several sailing ships and a mountainous landscape in the background.

Sag Harbor Marine Park

8.8/10 (20 reviews)

Sag Harbor Marine Park is just one of the places to see in Sag Harbor, so why not enjoy the other things to explore during your travels? While you're in the area, stroll along the beautiful beaches.

See properties

Frequently asked questions

What's the area like around Bay Street Theatre?

Bay Street Theatre is located in an area of Sag Harbor known for its beautiful beaches. If you're looking for a convenient place to stay, check out the 96 hotels and other accommodations you'll find within a mile.

What's the best place to stay near Bay Street Theatre?

Faraway Sag Harbor is one of the top choices for your stay based on our traveler data, and this hotel offers a restaurant and free valet parking. It's located just a short 0.3 mi (0.5 km) from Bay Street Theatre. Another good choice is Sag Harbor Inn, located just 0.4 mi (0.6 km) away.

How many hotels will I find near Bay Street Theatre?

Expedia has 96 hotels and other accommodations within a mile from Bay Street Theatre.

If I need to cancel the hotel reservation for my stay near Bay Street Theatre, will I receive a refund?

Yes! The majority of hotel reservations are fully refundable if you cancel prior to the hotel's cancellation deadline, which in most cases is within 24 or 48 hours of your arrival date. If you have a non-refundable reservation, you might be able to cancel it and receive a refund within a 24-hour period of your booking. Put your dates in and click on "Search", then filter by "fully refundable" to view the best deals near Bay Street Theatre.

Where can I learn more about changing or cancelling my trip in the area near Bay Street Theatre?

For more information about picking new dates or cancelling your stay near Bay Street Theatre, head over to our customer service page.

What can I see and do near Bay Street Theatre?

Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum, South Fork Natural History Museum and Nature Center, and Havens House feature captivating exhibits. Sights like St. David AME Zion Church and Eastville Heritage House highlight some of the local culture. Get outside and spend some time strolling around Mashomack Preserve, Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge, and Mashashimuet Park.

Find hotels near Bay Street Theatre, Sag Harbor from SAR 617

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Filter by

Property class

Guest rating

Our top choices for Bay Street Theatre hotels

1. Sag Harbor Inn

2. Faraway Sag Harbor

3. Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

4. The Bentley Hotel Southampton

5. The Shoals Suites and Slips

6. A Room At The Beach

7. East Hampton House Resort

8. Journey East Hampton

9. Bridgehampton Inn

10. Zey Hotel

11. House on Chase Creek

12. The Chequit

13. The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn

14. The Sagaponack

15. The Harbor Front Inn

16. East Hampton Art House Bed & Breakfast

17. The Huntting Inn

18. Topping Rose House

19. Mill House Inn

20. The Roundtree, Amagansett

Compare popular hotels close to Bay Street Theatre

Top Bay Street Theatre Hotel Reviews

The Sagaponack

Other attractions near Bay Street Theatre

Sag Harbor Marine Park

Frequently asked questions