Find 3 Star Hotels in Eagle Bay, NY
Plan, book, stay with confidence
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide
Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Check availability on Eagle Bay 3 Star Hotels
Compare Eagle Bay 3 Star Hotels with updated room rates, reviews, and availability. Most hotels are fully refundable.
Frequently asked questions
Recent reviews of Eagle Bay hotelsExpedia verified reviews
5/5 Excellent
"Wonder historic property. Right on the lake. Our hosts were wonderful and welcoming. Sense of seclusion and serenity yet walking distance to the hamlet’s shops and dining. We’ll make this a new favorite. "
A verified traveler stayed at The Woods Inn
Posted 6 days ago
5/5 Excellent
"Loved the laid back nature of the place- no front desk
Just arrive, take a life jacket and pull out a canoe and get busy enjoying the amazing lake.
Nothing fussy about the place. Restaurant was delicious/ top notch food. Low key staff that help anyway they can but don’t get in way. Firewood and all you need to enjoy your evening in quiet. I’d probably get bigger room
Next time .. our space for 4 was tight but I had cheap room "
A verified traveler stayed at Great Pines
Posted 8 days ago
Eagle Bay Hotels by Star Rating
Stay near popular Eagle Bay attractions
More Hotel Options in Eagle Bay
Explore more hotels
- Cozy Chalet with First Lake access just minutes from town. Great Location
- Adirondack Cabin w/Kayaks, Direct Snowmobile&ATV Trails, Swimming, Hiking, WiFi
- Quiet Adirondack Cabin on Private Lake!
- Brand New Luxury Cabin in Old Forge NY
- Cozy chalet across the road from marina; short walk to shops and restaurants.
- Waterfront Camp with Boathouse - Wifi, kayaks, canoe and sandy bottom out front.
- Matteson’s Rental Cabins
- Forestport Home w/ Access to Otter Lake
- Marina Motel
- Camp Bear Path - Cozy Cabin on Hollywood Hills Road with Lake Access
- Adirondack Mountain Lodge
- Peaceful Pines Cottage 5 minutes from Old Forge
- Warm & Cozy Adirondacks Cabin on Otter Lake!
- Cranberry Cottage Four Season Rental
- Waterfront Old Forge Cabin w/ Deck & Indoor Pool
- Old Forge Vacation Rental: Close to Downtown!
- Beautiful ADK Getaway! Trail 4 and Lake Access! Weekly Discount Available
- Adirondack Cottage - Four Season, Pet-Friendly, Cozy & Beautiful. Read reviews!
- Charming ADK Retreat Walking Distance to Town and River
- Charming, cozy, rustic Chalet.. Hollywood Hills, OLD FORGE, NY