Find 3 Star Hotels in Eagle Bay, NY
Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide
Check availability on Eagle Bay 3 Star Hotels
Compare Eagle Bay 3 Star Hotels with updated room rates, reviews, and availability. Most hotels are fully refundable.

Great Pines
Great Pines
8.6 out of 10, Excellent, (503)

The Woods Inn
The Woods Inn
8.6 out of 10, Excellent, (219)

1 Mi to Brantingham Lake: New York Getaway!
1 Mi to Brantingham Lake: New York Getaway!
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (1)

Forestport Home w/ Access to Otter Lake
Forestport Home w/ Access to Otter Lake

Private Deck & Fire Pit: Adirondack Family Home
Private Deck & Fire Pit: Adirondack Family Home

Thendara Cabin on Moose River w/ Game Room!
Thendara Cabin on Moose River w/ Game Room!

5-acre Brantingham Property w/ Porch & Grill!
5-acre Brantingham Property w/ Porch & Grill!

Conveniently Located Old Forge Condo Near Downtown
Conveniently Located Old Forge Condo Near Downtown
Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in
Learn more about Eagle Bay
Explore Eagle Bay: its mountain views, lake views, hiking, and more!

Top Eagle Bay Hotel Reviews

Great Pines
10/10 Excellent

The Woods Inn
10/10 Excellent
Explore a world of travel with Expedia
Explore a world of travel with Expedia
Eagle Bay Hotels by Star Rating
Stay near popular Eagle Bay attractions
- Hotels near Enchanted Forest Water Safari
- Hotels near Buttermilk Falls
- Hotels near View
- Hotels near Bald Mountain
- Hotels near Arrowhead Park
- Hotels near Calypso's Cove
- Hotels near Moose River
- Hotels near Fulton Chain Craft Brewery
- Hotels near McCauley Mountain Ski Center
- Hotels near Oswegatchie River
- Hotels near Black River
- Hotels near Rocky Mountain Trailhead
- Hotels near Lake Lila Primitive Area
- Hotels near Lake Lila
- Hotels near John Dillon Park
More Hotel Options in Eagle Bay
- Adventure Hotels in Eagle Bay
- Beach Hotels in Eagle Bay
- Family Hotels in Eagle Bay
- Golf Hotels in Eagle Bay
- Hotels with Bars in Eagle Bay
- Hotels with Free Parking in Eagle Bay
- Hotels with WiFi in Eagle Bay
- Hotels with a Pool in Eagle Bay
- Hotels with an Indoor Pool in Eagle Bay
- Hotels with smoking rooms in Eagle Bay
- Pet-friendly Hotels in Eagle Bay
- Resorts & Hotels with Spas in Eagle Bay
More Accommodation Types in Eagle Bay
Explore more hotels
- Adirondack Home Located Across From Enchanted Forest in the Heart of Old Forge
- Marina Motel
- Cabin close to town with lake access & hot tub
- Beautiful ADK Getaway! Trail 4 and Lake Access! Weekly Discount Available
- NEW ADIRONDACK LUXURY CABIN WITH YEAR-ROUND HEATED PLUNGE POOL
- Lakehouse Lodge ~ Fourth Lake Getaway Lodges
- Ronnie's Guest House
- Adirondack Cabin Retreat On West Branch of the Oswegatchie River!
- Spacious, immaculate home! Camp Pawnee
- Adirondack Cabin w/Kayaks, Direct Snowmobile&ATV Trails, Swimming, Hiking, WiFi
- Waterfront Camp with Boathouse - Wifi, kayaks, canoe and sandy bottom out front.
- Peaceful Pines Cottage 5 minutes from Old Forge
- Moose River ADK Get-Away
- Adorable Historic Adirondack Lakefront Cottage on Long Lake
- Matteson’s Rental Cabins
- Family Friendly River Cottage
- Cozy Main Street “The Guide’s Cottage”
- A secluded cabin on your own prvt pond. Serenity!
- Lakefront Escape, On Snowmobile Trail, Near Town
- Luxurious/Modern Adirondack home with gorgeous boathouse, sandbar & sunset view