Find 2 Star Hotels in Sylvan Beach, NY from SAR 334

"Boarded up"

"Stopped in July 2025. This is no longer a Motel 6. Expedia did refund my money. Arrived at night to a very dark location with no signage or lighting. Went inside and the employee told me I can cancel with Expedia and just pay him directly to stay. I immediately went out to my car and left. This should be removed from Expedia. "

"This was the perfect place for our family of four. It was close enough to family and it allowed us to be able to get a good night sleep with no concerns. The house was clean, warm enough, and really a great place for us to be able to stay. Will consider staying here again. "

"The property, which comprises 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, is centrally located in downtown Sylvan Beach right off Main Street close to restaurants and the Midway. It was very clean and provided all the necessary amenities to include towels, bedding, pots and pans. It includes central air plus a mini split system in the master bedroom. There’s also a washer/dryer unit. The owners were very accommodating and easy to reach. When I asked if there was a Keurig machine they said no but that they would...

"Took the kids and family for the weekend and the place was great. Perfect location and as advertised. "

"Friendly staff"

"Such an adorable place! We highly recommend this place!"

"Our entire "

"Amazing from start to finish. Took my gf here for her birthday. Jaw dropping experience. Incredibly unique. The bungalow was clean, way bigger than I expected and just beautiful. The animals were active. Got great photos. Firepit and s’mores were a bonus. 10/10"

"Great communication, lovely property, highly recommended "